California's Clear Controversy: Debating Equity in Airport Security

By Ivan PetrenkoApr 25, 2024 14:30 PMNews
Share:
People standing in the queque inside airport
People standing in the queque inside airport. Source: unsplash

California lawmakers are considering a new bill that could transform how private biometric security services like CLEAR operate at airports across the state. The proposed legislation, discussed in a recent Senate hearing, focuses on making these companies pay for their dedicated TSA staff.

Legislation Targets Biometric Security Services

The bill targets services that offer fast-track security access via biometric kiosks. CLEAR, a service providing expedited security for a $189 annual fee, allows members to bypass regular lines, using dedicated lanes instead. Currently operational in nine major Californian airports, CLEAR has been both praised for its efficiency and criticized for fostering inequality.

Arguments For and Against the Proposed Law

Supporters of the legislation argue that services like CLEAR exacerbate disparities by allowing wealthier travelers to buy their way past long queues, thus prioritizing their convenience over others'. Senator Josh Newman, a prominent critic, contends that CLEAR's benefits are overstated, suggesting that it merely permits line-cutting without enhancing overall airport efficiency or security. On the flip side, CLEAR defends its model by highlighting the job creation and service it provides to over one million Californians, contributing significantly to local economies with $13 million in revenue.

Airlines including Southwest and United oppose the bill, fearing it could lead to higher ticket prices by disrupting current revenue models that benefit from partnerships with services like CLEAR.

The debate continues as California confronts the broader implications of private security services at public transportation hubs, weighing the balance between business innovation and equitable access.

Top Articles
Can you use a cell phone on a plane: reasons for restrictions for cell phone owners and rules for a safe flight

Can you use a cell phone on a plane: reasons for restrictions for cell phone owners and rules for a safe flight

Jun 23, 2024 10:09 AM
Discover the charm of Edinburgh with one of the city's best hotels

Top 10 hotels in Edinburgh: from luxury to comfort

Jun 22, 2024 08:14 AM

An easy way to find your past flight information

Jun 21, 2024 22:52 PM

San Francisco hotels that won't go broke: 10 affordable options

Jun 20, 2024 08:05 AM
More News
Arc de Triomphe in Barcelona, ​​Spain, with palm trees and people

Barcelona to Ban Short-Term Tourist Rentals by 2028 in a Bid to Curb Housing Crisis

Jun 24, 2024 05:30 AM
Sign reading 'One World' with a painted globe

Climate Activists' Airport Mishap in London

Jun 24, 2024 04:30 AM

Super-Size Your Farm Shop Experience with a Food Tour of South Devon

Jun 24, 2024 03:30 AM

Thailand Welcomes Digital Nomads with Extended Visa Program

Jun 24, 2024 02:30 AM
person wearing red jacket and blue denim jeans pulling luggage bag while walking on pathway

SITA Credits Technology for Reduction in Mishandled Bags

Jun 24, 2024 01:30 AM
Heathrow Terminal 5, Longford, Hounslow, UK

United Airlines Celebrates 10 Years at Heathrow with Exclusive Lounge

Jun 24, 2024 00:30 AM
A souvenir shop filled with colorful folk art items

New Rules for Souvenirs in Barcelona – What Souvenirs You Won’t See Anymore?

Jun 24, 2024 00:05 AM
A person wearing red sneakers relaxes on a train, with their feet propped up on a suitcase next to a window showing blurred scenery

What European Train Operators' Missed Opportunity Means for Travelers

Jun 23, 2024 23:30 PM
Delta Airlines taking off

Delta Air Lines Airbus A321neo Diverts to Boston Logan Due to Engine Issues

Jun 23, 2024 22:30 PM

Explore Fermanagh Lakelands with Summer Translink Service

Jun 23, 2024 21:30 PM

DHL Considers Short-Haul Widebody Overnight Flights for Fleet Renewal in Europe

Jun 23, 2024 20:30 PM
A green Stagecoach bus passing under a graffiti-covered bridge at sunset

Stagecoach East Enhances Travel Experience with PlusBus E-Ticket Trial

Jun 23, 2024 19:30 PM
Airbus A220 prepares to land

Delta One Passengers to Receive Luxury Amenity Kits by Missoni

Jun 23, 2024 18:30 PM
Two modern trains stationed at a railway platform

Upcoming Theme Park Promises Bigger Railway Station and Better Travel Experience

Jun 23, 2024 17:36 PM
Delta Connection soaring above the clouds

Delta Air Lines Flight Returns to West Palm Beach After Engine Fire

Jun 23, 2024 16:30 PM

Zenobē and Big Bus Tours Introduce Electric Buses for London Sightseeing

Jun 23, 2024 15:30 PM

Return of Cruise Liners Victory I and Victory II to the Great Lakes in 2025

Jun 23, 2024 14:30 PM
Worker in high-visibility vest and yellow boots standing inside a large railway tunnel under maintenance

Severn Tunnel Closure: Major Impact on Travelers Between South Wales and Bristol

Jun 23, 2024 13:32 PM
Eiffel Tower in Paris at sunset

France's Travel Boom: Record-Breaking Year for Tourism

Jun 23, 2024 12:34 PM
Graffiti on a wall that reads "LET'S STRIKE" in black letters

Liverpool Travelers Face Disruptions as Bus Drivers Plan Summer Strikes

Jun 23, 2024 11:35 AM
Aer Lingus airplane on the runway

Aer Lingus Cancels Flights Amid Industrial Action

Jun 23, 2024 10:32 AM
Aerial view of a busy street in Barcelona with taxis, a tourist bus, and street vendors

Huge Discounts on Travel for Young Adults in Spain

Jun 23, 2024 09:30 AM

Air France Unveils New Luxurious Lounge at LAX

Jun 23, 2024 08:34 AM

Stirling Hosts 13th Bloody Scotland Festival for Crime Fiction Enthusiasts

Jun 23, 2024 07:30 AM
Delta Air Lines airplane in flight

Delta Launches New Nonstop Flights from Orlando to London Heathrow This Winter

Jun 23, 2024 06:32 AM
Aerial view of Staffordshire, showcasing towns, villages, and lush green fields

Staffordshire Unveils Plan to Enhance Bus Services for Travelers

Jun 23, 2024 05:30 AM